Sometimes you like a song, because it reminds you a certain time, person or place.
You buy the album, and then you find that it's all just too similar; it dilutes the essence of the original moment, making the overall experience less than what it was.
I wonder if tying up all those emotions in one "event" can have the same outcome in real life? Rather than fearing that possibility, I believe you need to embrace any potential opportunities before dismissing them out of hand.
Just don't expect them all to work out, no matter how hard you cross your fingers.